University of Pennsylvania

Speakers and Controversy and Speakers, Oh My

Guest speakers are a regular part of campus life, and this week saw the ripples of controversial speakers on two campuses in the northeast. First up was an only mildly controversial event at Boston College. The Heights has a full article on the event, billed as “Understanding Christian Support for Israel,” in which speaker JoAnn Magnuson attempted to explain her support for Israel as a Christian Zionist. It was a small, relatively tame event until the question & answer period:

The majority of questions targeted Magnuson’s presentation. The audience members who spoke were all extremely passionate about their views, prompting a guarded response from Magnuspm. Cunningham responded to most of the questions, as Magnuson was visibly uncomfortable after the questions began…

A woman from Lebanon, whose husband is a Palestinian, challenged Magnuson’s support of Christian Zionism as means of achieving justice, saying instead that it ‘taught hatred of Islam.’

‘As a Jew, as a lover of Israel, the coalition of Christian Zionists, the Christian right, and the Israeli right has a very devastating potential for Jews and Israel,’ said Martin R. Federman, the co-chair of the Boston chapter of the Jewish Voice for Peace.

About 300 miles away at the University of Pennsylvania, divisions have cropped up regarding the school’s choice for a commencement speaker:

The University’s decision to bring James Baker to speak at this year’s Commencement may be raising concerns among pro-Israel and Jewish students… The Penn Israel Coalition has taken issue with the decision to bring the former U.S. cabinet member and co-chairman of the Iraq Study Group who famously clashed with the American Israel Public Affairs Committee in the past and is alleged to have made anti-Semitic remarks.

PIC President and Wharton and College junior Max Schapiro said it is ‘inappropriate’ for Penn to bring in an individual who is ’so offensive to so many in this community.’

This comes on the same day that prolific author and lawyer Alan Dershowitz (always good for a quote) spoke on campus. “Although slated to speak on global terrorism, the talk focused instead on the alarming rise of anti-semitism and what Dershowitz described as growing ‘delegitimization’ of Israel.” The event featured “a brief outburst during the question-and-answer session that required security guards to remove a disruptive audience member.”

The quote of the night probably came from Malcolm Hoenlein, vice chair of the Congress of Jewish Presidents and Dershowitz’s opening speaker: “It’s not politically correct to attack a Jew openly,” Hoenlein said. “So they attack the state that represents them.”

Alan Dershowitz comes to Penn March 14

Lawyer, author, Harvard law school professor, and much-famed defender of Israel Alan Dershowtiz is coming to speak at Penn March 14. The lecture, entitled, “Global Terrorism: The New World War,” will take place at the Annenberg Center of Performing Arts at 7:00 p.m.
Alan Dershowitz will discuss the threat of radical Islam around the world, especially in Israel and the Middle East. The event is hosted by Aish and the Penn Israel Coalition, with an opening address by Malcolm Hoenlein, Vice Chairman of the Congress of Presidents of Major Jewish Organizations. The event is receiving much publicity and is already generating a lot of excitement and anticipation in affiliated Jewish circles.
Student tickets are $5.00 ($15.00 at door), and can be purchased and picked up at the Zellerbach Theatre, Annenberg Center. Box Office Phone: 215-898-3900.

Questions? E-mail:
Max - maxw@wharton.upenn.edu
Rinat - rinatb@pobox.upenn.edu

More information:
http://upenn.facebook.com/event.php?eid=2231348600

Phone-a-Thon To Raise Funds for Israel

From the Hillel listserv:

On Sunday February 11 the Jewish Federation of Greater Philadelphia will be holding its annual Super Sunday event.
At this event thousands of people of all ages join together to create a giant phone-a-thon and raise funds for Israel as well as for the local Jewish community. Penn Hillel as part of Hillel of Greater Philadelphia is a significant beneficiary of the Federation, and is heavily recruiting student volunteers.
There will be a bus from Penn Hillel at 1 p.m. on Sunday which will take Penn participants to 4200 City Avenue and return to campus by 4 p.m. Penn’s Hillel will be offering a free pizza lunch at 12 p.m.

Yachad Shabbaton at Penn

“Yachad is finally here and we are so pumped to have them!” wrote Shalhevet Roth, Co-Chair of the Orthodox Community at Penn, in her most recent weekly e-mail sent out to the OCP listserv. Yachad is a program of the Orthodox Union that “provides unique social, educational and recreational ‘mainstreamed’ programs for individuals (ages 8-40) with developmental disabilities,” according to its Website.
This weekend, 12 Yachad members and 16 advisors came to Penn and stayed in Rodin College House, the on-campus High Rise where most of the Orthodox Jewish students reside in, or with students off-campus. They arrived on Friday, joined the Jewish community for a festive Tu B’shvat-themed dinner at Hillel, and afterwards had a “Yachad Oneg” in which all students were invited to participate. On Saturday morning they learned the Torah portion with several members of the community, and after lunch spent the afternoon taking a tour around Penn’s campus, playing Taboo, or just hanging out with members of Penn’s Jewish student body. After each meal, the male students would dance and sing with the Yachad members around the tables, which is rarely done on an average Shabbat.
“That is basically the whole point of the shabbaton, [for Penn students] to mingle with
Yachad members,” said Julia Klein, one of the Penn students who coordinated the Shabbaton.

CJLS Member at Hillel Friday

Rabbi Dr. Pamela Barmash, a professor of Hebrew Bible and Biblical Hebrew, is set to speak at Hillel this Friday after Shabbat dinner. Barmash, a member of the Conservative Committee on Jewish Law and Standards, was one of the 25 Rabbis who voted on the recent tshuvah regarding Homosexuality; her vote was one of the 13 that carried the tshuvah to passage.
Barmash has also been selected as the Scholar-in-Residence for the Upcoming Koach Kallah at the University of Pennsylvania.

Shabbat Roundup: Schiffman, Guttman, And “Cholympics”

A world-renowned scholar, our university president, and 12 pots of cholent were the highlights of Shabbat at Penn this weekend. Scholar-in-residence Lawrence Schiffman delivered a lively lecture on Friday night, University President Amy Gutmann attended Friday night dinner at Hillel, and 12 students created their tastiest crock-pot concoctions for “Cholympics” at Saturday Kiddush.
Over 100 students heard Schiffman, chairman of the Judaic studies department at NYU and Dead Sea Scrolls scholar, discuss “Who Was a Jew? Controversies Over Jewish Identity from Ancient to Modern Times.”
“We spend over $6 million doing surveys, and we still don’t know how many Jews there are in America,” he said, addressing the issue of how one defines a Jew in contemporary society. When the lecture ended at 10 p.m., some students stayed late to ask him questions. On Saturday afternoon Schiffman discussed “Who Wrote the Bible? Orthodoxy and Biblical Criticism.”
Students found Schiffman’s manner engaging.
“He is so charismatic!” noted Judah Greenberg, a med student at Penn.
Amy Gutmann’s participation in Friday night services caused much excitement in the student body. The Jewish university president sat with Hillel student leaders and members of the Muslim Student Association, moving around around the table to converse with different students.
“It was very casual. We were just schmoozing,” said Hillel’s Finance Chair Tina Yaniv.
The weekend was topped off by the annual cholent competition, or “Cholympics.” Twelve students prepared their secret recipes, including such special ingredients as Jack Daniel’s, for the students to consume and critique. A panel of four students, unaware of who made what cholent, sampled the creations, and in their deliberations referred to the number posted on the pots. In the face of stiff competition, Elie Gittler was pronounced the unanimous winner. Panelist Neta Tenenhaus noted that one cholent tasted “like kugel, and another one tasted like barbecue sauce.”
Needless to say, neither of these two cholents belonged to Gittler.

Many Israel Speakers This Semester

It’s only the first week of second semester, but the Penn Israel Coalition’s agenda is already brimming with Israel-related events, speakers, and pedagogic material.
Their first meeting of the semester took place in Steinhardt Hall (the Penn Hillel) on Sunday evening at 5 p.m. A humble showing of twelve students, mostly freshmen, attended the forty-five minute conference. The session primarily served to present an overview of the events planned for the semester and request for volunteers to assist in their preparation, and to generate more ideas for Israel advocacy on campus.
The Coalition has assembled an impressive list of speakers for the semester. Aryeh Green, an adviser to Natan Sharansky, comes to Penn
 on Monday, January 29 to address human rights, freedom, and the “apartheid fallacy” in Israel and the Middle 
East. Nonie Darwish is speaking at an undetermined date about her experiences both as a female Palestinian journalist and as the daughter of a martyr.
Then, Walid Shoebat, a former PLO terrorist, will discuss his life, why he renounced terrorism, and why he’s “on Israel’s side.” The date for Shoebat’s arrival is also currently undetermined.
Walid Phares, Senior Fellow at the Center for Defense of Democracies and a Lebanese Christian who has testified before Congress, is scheduled for sometime in February to discuss radical Islamic terror, and to encourage moderate Muslims to speak out. In early April, PIC will be hosting a panel discussion about Iran, 
Israel and America, featuring panelists from the moderate Avery Goldstein
 to the right-wing Daniel Pipes, with a left-wing speaker to be decided.
The meager attendance at the meeting does not imply weakness in man-power—-among the Jewish students who are active in Penn’s Hillel, the vast majority are active supporters of the Penn Israel Coalition. Many of the volunteers for the scheduled events were not present at the meeting on Sunday, but PIC keeps its membership updated through its listserv.

“A Toast on the Coast”: Penn Hillel’s Formal-turned-Charity Ball

Over 110 Jewish Penn students paid $25 to support NATAL — a non-partisan organization that aids Israeli victims of terror — chug alcohol at an open bar, feast on Oreos and Twizzlers and grind to Shakira last Thursday night.
The annual Hillel Formal was transformed into the Hillel Charity Ball, allowing students to justify splurging on a dance through the fact that it represented a good cause. The Charity Ball ran from 10:30-2:00 at the chic club Positano Coast in downtown Philadelphia, and raised more than $1,000 enough to cover expenses and still donate a substantial amount to the charity, according to a Social Committee official. The precise amount of the surplus has not yet been determined.
The range of Judaic affiliation of those present spanned the gamut, from Orthodox to Reconstructionist to non-affiliated. Most of the students present were those who play a visible role in the Penn Hillel, but a considerable amount were Jewish students who just went to have a good time. Penn’s Conservative Rabbi Michael Uram attended the beginning of the ball.
Although some students expressed reservations about the political character of the charity involved, the majority seemed wholly supportive of it.
The first few hours primarily consisted of taking advantage of the open bar — the Social Committee covered the first $400 worth of drinks — and schmoozing. The dancing picked up at around midnight and didn’t wane until the club closed at 2:00, at which point the partiers picked up their shoes and headed out for an early breakfast at Lorrenzo’s, a nearby pizza shop.

Comedian Joel Chasnoff @ Penn

“Have you ever noticed how laid-back everything is in Israel? They don’t dress up for anything! It’s Shabbat? Okay, I’ll wear a belt. Rosh Hashana? Pants with a belt.”
Joel Chasnoff performed for a group of around 125 Penn students and staff this past Friday night, to an appreciative audience of primarily Orthodox and Conservative Jews who had just completed Friday night dinner at Hillel.
Chasnoff, who had an observant upbringing, threw in phrases of Hebrew, and delivered jokes about Israel and religion. He played to his audience, and they ate it up.
A Penn alum turned professional comedian, Chasnoff has performed in seven countries at some of the world’s premier comedy venues. According to his Website, though, it is in the Jewish world of comedy that his “Innovative experience-based, positive Jewish humor has garnered him a cult-like following among the People of the Book and widespread recognition in the Jewish press.”
After graduating, Chasnoff served in a combat unit in the Israel Defense Forces, and at the end of his service performed stand-up comedy for soldiers on bases throughout Israel. He now lives in New York City with his two identical twin girls, who scampered about during the performance and won the heart of many a Penn woman.
The students, somewhat jaded and reluctant to hear a comedian after an abysmal experience with one last year, expressed how much they enjoyed the performance.
“I’ve heard him before… He came to my camp, but he had some new ones tonight; he was really funny,” said Conservative Jewish Community co-chair Elliot Gordon.

Rabbi Avi Weiss Speaks at Penn

“Faith & Leadership” was the topic of discussion as Rabbi Avi Weiss, founder of Yeshivat Chovevei Torah, spoke Wednesday night at Hillel. Weiss discussed his concept of “Open Judaism,” which he a strain of Orthodoxy that he explained embraces six ideas: the rejection of the approach of daat torah, or reliance on leading rabbis for instruction in most areas of life, in favor of more Jewish learning combined with secular studies, and rabbis and individuals making their own decisions; concern for all Jews; open support for the modern State of Israel; greater roles for women; Pluralism; public political protest and activism.




Advertisements