To “Jew” Or Not To “Jew”

A discussion over who gets student funds quickly turned ugly at Iowa State University, after the Hillel’s request for money to buy Haggadot was met with an odd - and possibly anti-Semitic - response from a student senator.
Student leaders at ISU needed to figure out who would get how much of their $1.45 million budget, Lisa Rossi reports for the Des Moines Register. The school has about 200 Jewish students.
Then the discussion got interesting:

Members of ISU Hillel have questioned the intentions of one student leader, Jason O’Leary, who reportedly said during a student government meeting last month that if “they’ve been Jew,” people should already have the religious book being discussed. He reportedly then said that if they “turn Jew,” he was unsure whether they’d have the book.
O’Leary, 24, an ISU student senator, said he wasn’t trying to be anti-Semitic at the meeting. He was in a minority of senators who voted against giving the group money but said he stood up and apologized at the end of the meeting to anyone he had offended.
“I said if people were already Jew - meaning if they were already Jewish,” he said, adding that he believed he said the word “Jew” only once during the meeting. “There were people (who) didn’t like me using the word. I didn’t know it was offensive.”
Members of the student government ultimately voted to give $376 to the ISU Hillel.
[…]
Ian Guffy [pictured above], an ISU student government member and president of ISU Hillel, said the debate over whether to spend cash on ISU Hillel highlighted the need for more awareness on campus of the proper ways to refer to Jewish students.
“Somebody is not ‘Jew,’ ” said Guffy, 20. “I don’t know what part of speech that is. That does not work.”
Ron Jackson, an ISU psychologist and adviser to ISU Hillel, said referring to someone as “Jew” is more objectifying than saying he or she is Jewish.
“A Jew - that’s all that matters,” he said. “That defines the totality of the person. That’s also how the Germans used ‘Yid.’ If someone’s a Yid, you kill them.”

3 Responses to “To "Jew" Or Not To "Jew"”


  1. 1 Ian Guffy Nov 6th, 2006 at 1:37 pm

    For the record, the debate did not “quicly turn ugly.” The vast majority of the debate was respectful and NOT anti-semitic. Most of the debate was about what kind or precedent this funding would set, which required discussion of what exactly a Haggadah is. The rest of the Senate was aghast at Senator O’Leary’s comments, which he appologised for, and further debate did not echo the unintentional sentiment of his remarks.

    The student newspaper’s article can be found here:
    http://www.iowastatedaily.com/media/storage/paper818/news/2006/10/26/News/Gsb-Debates.Funding.For.Jewish.Group-2402608.shtml?norewrite200611061536&sourcedomain=www.iowastatedaily.com

    The minutes of the Oct. 25th debate are available here:
    http://www.gsb.iastate.edu/meetings/agendasminutes.php

    - Ian Guffy
    ISU Hillel President
    ISU Government of the Student Body Senator

  2. 2 Jim Jensen Nov 6th, 2006 at 4:54 pm

    Unbelievable. Ultra hypersensitive jews. Get a life.

  3. 3 jayjo Nov 10th, 2006 at 3:19 pm

    Got to say, coming from the Midwest cornfields, that it sounds to me like he just didn’t understand the word usage. Been there, done that.

Leave a Reply




Advertisements